scst/scst

Generic SCSI target mid-level for Linux (SCST)
==============================================

Version 0.9.5, XX XXX 2006
--------------------------

SCST is designed to provide unified, consistent interface between SCSI
target drivers and Linux kernel and simplify target drivers development
as much as possible. Detail description of SCST's features and internals
could be found in "Generic SCSI Target Middle Level for Linux" document
SCST's Internet page http://scst.sourceforge.net.

SCST looks to be quite stable (for beta) and useful. It supports disks
(SCSI type 0), tapes (type 1), processor (type 3), CDROM's (type 5), MO
disks (type 7), medium changers (type 8) and RAID controller (type 0xC).
There are also FILEIO and "performance" device handlers. In addition,
starting from version 0.9.3 advanced per-initiator access and devices
visibility management is added, so different initiators could see
different set of devices with different access permissions. See below
for details.

This is more or less stable (but still beta) version.

Tested mostly on "vanilla" 2.6.17.8 kernel from kernel.org.

Device handlers
---------------

Device specific drivers (device handlers) are plugins for SCST, which
help SCST to analyze incoming requests and determine parameters,
specific to various types of devices. If an appropriate device handler
for a SCSI device type isn't loaded, SCST doesn't know how to handle
devices of this type, so they will be invisible for remote initiators
(more precisely, "LUN not supported" sense code will be returned).

In addition to device handlers for real devices, there are FILEIO and
"performance" ones.

FILEIO device handler works over files on file systems and makes from
them virtual remotely available SCSI disks or CDROM's. In addition, it
allows to work directly over a block device, e.g. local IDE or SCSI disk
or ever disk partition, where there is no file systems overhead. Using
block devices comparing to sending SCSI commands directly to SCSI
mid-level via scsi_do_req() has advantage that data are transfered via
system cache, so it is possible to fully benefit from caching and read
ahead performed by Linux's VM subsystem. The only disadvantage here that
there is superfluous data copying between the cache and SCST's buffers.
This issue is going to be addressed in the next release. Virtual CDROM's
are useful for remote installation. See below for details how to setup
and use FILEIO device handler.

"Performance" device handlers for disks, MO disks and tapes in their
exec() method skip (pretend to execute) all READ and WRITE operations
and thus provide a way for direct link performance measurements without
overhead of actual data transferring from/to underlying SCSI device.
Starting from 0.9.3 these handlers are incorporated inside of
corresponding device handler for real device and could be assigned on
run-time via "assign" command in "/proc/scsi_tgt/scsi_tgt" (see below).

NOTE: Since "perf" device handlers on READ operations don't touch the
====  commands' data buffer, it is returned to remote initiators as it
      was allocated, without even being zeroed. Thus, "perf" device
      handlers impose some security risk, so use them with caution.

Installation
------------

At first, make sure that the link "/lib/modules/`you_kernel_version`/build" 
points to the source code for your currently running kernel.

Then, if you are going to work on 2.6 kernels, since in those kernels
scsi_do_req() works in LIFO order, instead of expected and required
FIFO, SCST needs a new function scsi_do_req_fifo() to be added in the
kernel. Patch 26_scst.patch (or 26_scst-2.6.14-.patch for early kernels)
from "kernel" directory does that. If it doesn't apply to your kernel
version, apply it manually, it only adds that function and nothing more.
You may not patch the kernel if STRICT_SERIALIZING is defined during the
compilation (see its description below).

To compile SCST go to 'src' directory and type 'make' on 2.6 kernels and
'make -f Makefile-24' on 2.4 ones. It will build SCST itself and its
device handlers. To install them type 'make install'. The driver modules
will be installed in
'/lib/modules/`you_kernel_version`/kernel/drivers/scsi/scsi_tgt' on 2.4
kernels and in '/lib/modules/`you_kernel_version`/extra' on 2.6 ones. In
addition, scsi_tgt.h, scst_debug.h and scst_debug.c will be copied to
'/usr/local/include/scst'. The first file contains all SCST's public
data definition, which are used by target drivers. The other ones
support debug messages logging.

Then you can load any module by typing 'modprobe drive_name'. The names are:

 - scsi_tgt - SCST itself
 - scst_disk - device handler for disks (type 0)
 - scst_tape - device handler for tapes (type 1)
 - scst_processor - device handler for processors (type 3)
 - scst_cdrom - device handler for CDROMs (type 5)
 - scst_modisk - device handler for MO disks (type 7)
 - scst_changer - device handler for medium changers (type 8)
 - scst_raid - device handler for storage array controller (e.g. raid) (type C)
 - scst_fileio - device handler for FILE IO (disk or ISO CD image).

Then, to see your devices remotely, you need to add them to at least
"Default" security group (see below how). By default, no local devices
are seen remotely. There must be LUN 0 in each security group, i.e. LUs
numeration must not start from, e.g., 1.

Module "scst_target" supports parameter "scst_threads", which allows to
set count of SCST's threads (CPU count by default).

IMPORTANT: without loading appropriate device handler, corresponding devices
=========  will be invisible for remote initiators, which could lead to holes
           in the LUN addressing, so automatic device scanning by remote SCSI 
           mid-level could not notice the devices. Therefore you will have 
	   to add them manually via 
	   'echo "scsi add-single-device A 0 0 B" >/proc/scsi/scsi',
	   where A - is the host number, B - LUN.

IMPORTANT 1: In the current version simultaneous access to local SCSI
===========  devices via standard high-level SCSI drivers (sd, st, sg,
             etc.) and SCST's target drivers is unsupported. Especially
	     it is important for execution via sg and st commands that
	     change the state of devices and their parameters, because
	     that could lead to data corruption. If any such command
	     is done, at least related device handler driver(s) must be
	     restarted. For block devices READ/WRITE commands using direct
	     disk handler look to be safe.

To uninstall, type 'make uninstall'. It is not implemented for 2.6
kernels.

If you install QLA2x00 target driver's source code in this directory,
then you can build, install or uninstall it by typing 'make qla', 'make
qla_install' or 'make qla_uninstall' correspondingly. Or 'make qla26',
'make qla26_install' or 'make qla26_uninstall' for new 2.6 driver. For
more details about QLA2x00 target drivers see their README files.

Compilation options
-------------------

There are the following compilation options, that could be commented
in/out in Makefile:

 - DEBUG - turns on some debugging code, including some logging. Makes
   the driver considerably bigger and slower, producing large amount of
   log data.

 - TRACING - turns on ability to log events. Makes the driver considerably
   bigger and lead to some performance loss.

 - EXTRACHECKS - adds extra validity checks in the various places.

 - DEBUG_TM - turns on task management functions debugging, when on
   LUN 0 in the "Default" group some of the commands will be delayed for
   about 60 sec., so making the remote initiator send TM functions, eg
   ABORT TASK and TARGET RESET. Also set TM_DBG_GO_OFFLINE symbol in the
   Makefile to 1 if you want that the device eventually become
   completely unresponsive, or to 0 otherwise to circle around ABORTs
   and RESETs code. Needs DEBUG turned on.

 - STRICT_SERIALIZING - makes SCST send all commands to underlying SCSI
   device synchronously, one after one. This makes task management more
   reliable, with cost of some performance penalty. This is mostly
   actual for stateful SCSI devices like tapes, where the result of
   command's execution depends from device's settings set by previous
   commands. Disk and RAID devices are stateless in the most cases. The
   current SCSI core in Linux doesn't allow to abort all commands
   reliably if they sent asynchronously to a stateful device. Turned off
   by default, turn it on if you use stateful device(s) and need as much
   error recovery reliability as possible. As a side effect, no kernel
   patching is necessary.

 - SCST_HIGHMEM - if defined on HIGHMEM systems with 2.6 kernels, it
   allows SCST to use HIGHMEM. This is very experimental feature and it
   is unclear, if it brings something valuable, except some performance
   hit, so in the current version it is disabled. Note, that
   SCST_HIGHMEM isn't required for HIGHMEM systems and SCST will work
   fine on them with SCST_HIGHMEM off. Untested.
  
 - SCST_STRICT_SECURITY - if defined, makes SCST zero allocated data
   buffers. Undefining it (default) considerably improves performance
   and eases CPU load, but could create a security hole (information
   leakage), so enable it, if you have strict security requirements.

SCST "/proc" commands
---------------------

For communications with user space programs SCST provides proc-based
interface in "/proc/scsi_tgt" directory. It contains the following
entries:

  - "help" file, which provides online help for SCST commands
  
  - "scsi_tgt" file, which on read provides information of serving by SCST
    devices and their dev handlers. On write it supports the following
    command:
    
      * "assign H:C:I:L HANDLER_NAME" assigns dev handler "HANDLER_NAME" 
        on device with host:channel:id:lun

  - "sessions" file, which lists currently connected initiators (open sessions)
	
  - "threads" file, which allows to read and set number of SCST's threads
  
  - "version" file, which shows version of SCST
  
  - "trace_level" file, which allows to read and set trace (logging) level
    for SCST. See "help" file for list of trace levels.

Each dev handler has own subdirectory. Most dev handler have only two
files in this subdirectory: "trace_level" and "type". The first one is
similar to main SCST "trace_level" file, the latter one shows SCSI type
number of this handler as well as some text description.

For example, "echo "assign 1:0:1:0 dev_disk" >/proc/scsi_tgt/scsi_tgt"
will assign device handler "dev_disk" to real device sitting on host 1,
channel 0, ID 1, LUN 0.

Access and devices visibility management
----------------------------------------

Access and devices visibility management allows for an initiator or
group of initiators to have different limited set of LUs/LUNs (security
group) each with appropriate access permissions. Initiator is
represented as a SCST session. Session is binded to security group on
its registration time by character "name" parameter of the registration
function, which provided by target driver, based on its internal
authentication. For example, for FC "name" could be WWN or just loop
ID. For iSCSI this could be iSCSI login credentials or iSCSI initiator
name. Each security group has set of names assigned to it by system
administrator. Session is binded to security group with provided name.
If no such groups found, the session binded to "Default" group.

In /proc/scsi_tgt each group represented as "groups/GROUP_NAME/"
subdirectory. In it there are files "devices" and "users". File
"devices" lists all devices and their LUNs in the group, file "users"
lists all names that should be binded to this group.

To configure access and devices visibility management SCST provides the
following files and directories under /proc/scsi_tgt:

  - "add_group GROUP" to /proc/scsi_tgt/scsi_tgt adds group "GROUP"
  
  - "del_group GROUP" to /proc/scsi_tgt/scsi_tgt deletes group "GROUP"
  
  - "add H:C:I:L lun [RO]" to /proc/scsi_tgt/groups/GROUP/devices adds 
    device with host:channel:id:lun as LUN "lun" in group "GROUP". Optionally,
    the device could be marked as read only.
  
  - "del H:C:I:L" to /proc/scsi_tgt/groups/GROUP/devices deletes device with
    host:channel:id:lun from group "GROUP"
  
  - "add V_NAME lun [RO]" to /proc/scsi_tgt/groups/GROUP/devices adds device with
    virtual name "V_NAME" as LUN "lun" in group "GROUP". Optionally, the device 
    could be marked as read only.
  
  - "del V_NAME" to /proc/scsi_tgt/groups/GROUP/devices deletes device with
    virtual name "V_NAME" from group "GROUP"
  
  - "clear" to /proc/scsi_tgt/groups/GROUP/devices clears the list of devices
    for group "GROUP"
  
  - "add NAME" to /proc/scsi_tgt/groups/GROUP/names adds name "NAME" to group 
    "GROUP"
  
  - "del NAME" to /proc/scsi_tgt/groups/GROUP/names deletes name "NAME" from group 
    "GROUP"
  
  - "clear" to /proc/scsi_tgt/groups/GROUP/names clears the list of names
    for group "GROUP"

Examples:

 - "echo "add 1:0:1:0 0" >/proc/scsi_tgt/groups/Default/devices" will
 add real device sitting on host 1, channel 0, ID 1, LUN 0 to "Default"
 group with LUN 0.

 - "echo "add disk1 1" >/proc/scsi_tgt/groups/Default/devices" will
 add virtual FILEIO device with name "disk1" to "Default" group
 with LUN 1. 

FILEIO device handler
---------------------

After loading FILEIO device handler creates in "/proc/scsi_tgt/"
subdirectories "disk_fileio" and "cdrom_fileio". They have similar layout:

  - "trace_level" and "type" files as described for other dev handlers
  
  - "help" file, which provides online help for FILEIO commands
  
  - "disk_fileio"/"cdrom_fileio" files, which on read provides
    information of currently open device files. On write it supports the
    following command:
    
    * "open NAME PATH [FLAGS]" - opens file "PATH" as device "NAME" with 
      flags "FLAGS. Possible flags:
      
      - WRITE_THROUGH - write back caching disabled
      
      - READ_ONLY - read only
      
      - O_DIRECT - both read and write caching disabled (doesn't work
        currently).

      - NULLIO - in this mode no real IO will be done, but success will be
        returned. Intended to be used for performance measurements at the same
        way as "*_perf" handlers.
    
    * "close NAME" - closes device "NAME".

For example, "echo "open disk1 /vdisks/disk1" >/proc/scsi_tgt/disk_fileio/disk_fileio"
will open file /vdisks/disk1 as virtual FILEIO disk with name "disk1".

IMPORTANT: by default for performance reasons FILEIO devices use write back
=========  caching policy, so if you care about the consistence of file systems,
           laying over them, and your data you must supply your target
           server with some king of UPS or disable write back caching
           via WRITE_THROUGH flag. The FS joutnaling over write back
           caching enabled devices doesn't protect from power failures
           on the target side, therefore even after successful journal
           rollback you very much risk to loose your data.

Performance
-----------

Before doing any performance measurements note that:

I. Maximum performance is possible only with real SCSI devices or
performance handlers. FILEIO handler isn't optimized for performance
yet, although, if you have enough CPU power, it could provide very
acceptable results, when aggregate throughput is close to aggregate
throuput locally on the target on the same disks.

II. In order to get the maximum performance you should:

1. For SCST:

 - Disable in Makefile STRICT_SERIALIZING, EXTRACHECKS, TRACING, DEBUG,
   SCST_STRICT_SECURITY, SCST_HIGHMEM

2. For Qlogic target driver:

 - Disable in Makefile EXTRACHECKS, TRACING, DEBUG_TGT, DEBUG_WORK_IN_THREAD

3. For device handlers, including FILEIO:

 - Disable in Makefile TRACING, DEBUG

IMPORTANT: Some of those options enabled by default, i.e. SCST is optimized
=========  currently rather for development, not for performance.

4. For kernel:

 - Don't enable debug/hacking features, i.e. use them as they are by
   default.

 - The default kernel read-ahead and queuing settings are optimized
   for locally attached disks, therefore they are not optimal if they
   attached remotly (our case), which sometimes could lead to unexpectedly
   low throughput. You should increase read-ahead size
   (/sys/block/device/queue/read_ahead_kb) for at least 256Kb or even
   more on all initiators and the target. Also experiment with other
   parameters in /sys/block/device directory, they also affect the
   performance. If you find the best values, please share them with us.

5. For hardware.

 - Make sure that your target hardware (e.g. target FC card) and underlaying
   SCSI hardware (e.g. SCSI card to which your disks connected) stay on
   different PCI buses. They will have to work in parallel, so it
   will be better if they don't race for the bus. The problem is not
   only in the bandwidth, which they have to share, but also in the
   interaction between the cards during that competition. We have told
   that in some cases it could lead to 5-10 times less performance, than
   expected.

Just for reference: we had with 0.9.2 and "old" Qlogic driver on 2.4.2x
kernel, where we did carefull performance study, aggregate throuhput
about 390 Mb/sec from 2 qla2300 cards sitting on different 64-bit PCI
buses and working simultaneously for two different initiators with
several simultaneously working load programs on each. From one card -
about 190 Mb/sec. We used tape_perf handler, so there was no influence
from underlying SCSI hardware, i.e. we measured only SCST/FC overhead.
The target computer configuration was not very modern for the moment:
something like 2x1GHz Intel P3 Xeon CPUs. You can estimate the
memory/PCI speed from that. CPU load was ~5%, there were ~30K IRQ/sec
and no additional SCST related context switches. Version 0.9.3 at the
same setup will usually have 1 CS/cmd for buffer allocation, so the will
be about 5-10K CS/sec. This will be fixed in the next version, when
sgv_pool is integrated.

Credits
-------

Thanks to:

 * Mark Buechler <mark.buechler@gmail.com> for a lot of useful
   suggestions, bug reports and help in debugging.

 * Ming Zhang <mingz@ele.uri.edu> for fixes and comments.
 
 * Nathaniel Clark <nate@misrule.us> for fixes and comments.

 * Calvin Morrow <calvin.morrow@comcast.net> for testing and usful
   suggestions.

Vladislav Bolkhovitin <vst@vlnb.net>, http://scst.sourceforge.net