diff --git a/IMPLEMENTATION_SUMMARY.md b/IMPLEMENTATION_SUMMARY.md new file mode 100644 index 0000000000..d57c0296c7 --- /dev/null +++ b/IMPLEMENTATION_SUMMARY.md @@ -0,0 +1,85 @@ +# Tablet Migration RPC Decoupling - Implementation Summary + +## What Was Changed + +### Problem Statement +The topology_coordinator's `handle_tablet_migration()` function was tightly coupled with RPC sending, making it difficult to test in unit tests without setting up a full multi-node cluster. + +### Solution +Introduced an abstraction layer (`tablet_migration_rpc_handler`) that decouples the coordinator logic from actual RPC operations. + +## Files Added + +### 1. `service/tablet_migration_rpc_handler.hh` +Interface defining the RPC operations needed for tablet migration: +- `tablet_repair()` - Repair a tablet on a replica +- `tablet_stream_data()` - Stream tablet data to a replica +- `tablet_cleanup()` - Clean up tablet data on a replica +- `repair_update_compaction_ctrl()` - Update compaction controller after repair + +### 2. `test/lib/local_tablet_rpc_simulator.hh` +Test implementation that calls local RPC handlers instead of sending network RPCs. + +### 3. `docs/dev/tablet-migration-rpc-decoupling.md` +Documentation explaining the architecture and how to use it. + +## Files Modified + +### 1. `service/topology_coordinator.cc` +- Added `messaging_tablet_rpc_handler` class - production implementation that wraps `messaging_service` RPCs +- Updated `handle_tablet_migration()` to use `_tablet_rpc_handler` interface instead of direct RPC calls +- Updated constructor to accept optional RPC handler and initialize it +- Modified 5 locations where tablet RPCs were called: + - rebuild_repair stage → `tablet_repair()` + - streaming stage → `tablet_stream_data()` + - cleanup stage → `tablet_cleanup()` (2 locations) + - repair stage → `tablet_repair()` + - end_repair stage → `repair_update_compaction_ctrl()` + +### 2. `service/topology_coordinator.hh` +- Added forward declaration for `tablet_migration_rpc_handler` +- Updated `run_topology_coordinator()` signature to accept optional `tablet_rpc_handler` parameter + +## How It Works + +### Production Mode (Default) +```cpp +run_topology_coordinator(...); +// Automatically uses messaging_tablet_rpc_handler +``` + +The topology coordinator creates a `messaging_tablet_rpc_handler` that sends actual network RPCs. + +### Test Mode +```cpp +local_tablet_rpc_simulator simulator(storage_service); +run_topology_coordinator(..., std::make_unique(simulator)); +``` + +Tests can provide a `local_tablet_rpc_simulator` that calls local RPC handlers directly, bypassing the network layer. + +## Benefits + +1. **Testability**: Can now test `handle_tablet_migration()` logic in unit tests +2. **Separation of Concerns**: Coordinator logic (group0 transitions, barriers) is separated from replica logic (RPCs) +3. **Minimal Changes**: The refactoring is minimal and surgical - only abstracts the RPC layer +4. **Backward Compatible**: Existing code continues to work without changes + +## What Can Now Be Tested + +With this refactoring, tests can now: +1. Verify that tablet migrations progress through the correct stages +2. Test barrier coordination between stages +3. Test rollback logic when migrations fail +4. Test the interaction between migrations and topology changes +5. Simulate various failure scenarios at the RPC level + +All without needing multiple nodes or network communication. + +## Future Work + +This refactoring enables future enhancements: +1. More comprehensive topology coordinator unit tests +2. Fault injection at the RPC level in tests +3. Better simulation of network conditions +4. Potential extraction of more coordinator logic into testable components