It was auto-expanded only if the strategy name
was the short "NetworkTopologyStrategy" name.
Fixes#9302.
Closes#9304.
* 'prepare_options' of https://github.com/bhalevy/scylla:
cql3: keyspace prepare_options: expand replication_factor also for fully qualified NetworkTopologyStrategy
abstract_replication_strategy: add to_qualified_class_name
After a4053dbb72, data segregation is postponed to offstrategy, so reshape
procedure is called with disjoint sstables which belong to different
windows, so let's extend the optimization for disjoint sstables which
span more than one window. In this way, write amplification is reduced
for offstrategy compaction, as all disjoint sstables will be compacted
at once.
Signed-off-by: Raphael S. Carvalho <raphaelsc@scylladb.com>
Message-Id: <20211013203046.233540-2-raphaelsc@scylladb.com>
It was auto-expanded only if the strategy name
was the short "NetworkTopologyStrategy" name.
Fixes#9302
Test: cql_query_test.test_rf_expand(dev)
Signed-off-by: Benny Halevy <bhalevy@scylladb.com>
This mini series contains two fixes that are bundled together since the
second one assumes that the first one exists (or it will not fix
anything really...), the two problems were:
1. When certain operations are called on a service level controller
which doesn't have it's data accessor set, it can lead to a crash
since some operations will still try to dereference the accessor
pointer.
2. The cql environment test initialized the accessor with a
sharded<system_distributed_data>& however this sharded class as
itself is not initialized (sharded::start wasn't called), so for the
same that were unsafe for null dereference the accessor will now crash
for trying to access uninitialized sharded instance.
Closes#9468
* github.com:scylladb/scylla:
CQL test environment: Fix bad initialization order
Service Level Controller: Fix possible dereference of a null pointer
Before this patch, if Scylla crashes during some test in test/alternator,
all tests after it will fail because they can't connect to Scylla - and we
can get a report on hundreds of failures without a clear sign of where the
real problem was.
This patch introduces an autouse fixture (i.e., a fixture automatically
used by every test) which tries to run a do-nothing health-check request
after each test. If this health-check request fails, we conclude that
Scylla crashed and report the test in which this happened - and exit
pytest instead of failing a hundred more tests.
The failure report looks something like this:
```
! _pytest.outcomes.Exit: Scylla appears to have crashed in test test_batch.py::test_batch_get_item !
```
And the entire test run fails.
These extra health checks are not free, but they come fairly close to
being free: In my tests I measured less than 0.1 seconds slowdown of
the entire test suite (which has 618 tests) caused by the extra health
checks.
Fixes#9489
Signed-off-by: Nadav Har'El <nyh@scylladb.com>
Message-Id: <20211017123222.217559-1-nyh@scylladb.com>
Issue #9467 deprecated the blanket "--experimental" option which we
used to enable all experimental Scylla features for testing, and
suggests that individual experimental features should be enabled
instead.
So this is what we do in this patch for the Scylla-running scripts
in test/alternator and test/cql-pytest: We need to enable UDF for
the CQL tests, and to enable Alternator Streams and Alternator TTL
for the Alternator tests.
Refs #9467
Signed-off-by: Nadav Har'El <nyh@scylladb.com>
Message-Id: <20211012110312.719654-2-nyh@scylladb.com>
"
The current api design of abstract_replication_strategy
provides a can_yield parameter to calls that may stall
when traversing the token metadata in O(n^2) and even
in O(n) for a large number of token ranges.
But, to use this option the caller must run in a seastar thread.
It can't be used if the caller runs a coroutine or plain
async tasks.
Rather than keep adding threads (e.g. in storage_service::load_and_stream
or storage_service::describe_ring), the series offers an infrastructure
change: precalculating the token->endpoints map once, using an async task,
and keeping the results in a `effective_replication_map` object.
The latter can be used for efficient and stall-free calls, like
get_natural_endpoints, or get_ranges/get_primary_range, replacing their
equivalents in abstract_replication_strategy, and dropping the public
abstract_replication_strategy::calculate_natural_endpoints and its
internal cached_endpoints map.
Other than the performance benefits of:
1. The current calls require running a thread to yield.
Precalculating the map (using async task) allows us to use synchronous calls
without stalling the rector.
2. The replication maps can and should be shared
between keyspaces that use the same replication strategy.
(Will be sent as a follow-up to the series)
The bigger benefits (courtesy of Avi Kivity) are laying the groundwork for:
1. atomic replication metadata - an operation can capture a replication map once, and then use consistent information from the map without worrying that it changes under its feet. We may even be able to s/inet_address/replica_ptr/ later.
2. establish boundaries on the use of replication information - by making a replication map not visible, and observing when its reference count drops to zero, we can tell when the new replication map is fully in use. When we start writing to a new node we'll be able to locate a point in time where all writes that were not aware of the new node were completed (this is the point where we should start streaming).
Notes:
* The get_natural_endpoints method that uses the effective_replication_map
is still provided as a abstract_replication_strategy virtual method
so that local_strategy can override it and privide natural endpoints
for any search token, even in the absence of token_metadata, when\
called early-on, before token_metadata has been established.
The effective_replication_map materializes the replication strategy
over a given replication strategy options and token_metadata.
Whenever either of those change for a keyspace, we make a new
effective_replication_map and keep it in the keyspace for latter use.
Methods that depend on an ad-hoc token_metadata (e.g. during
node operations like bootstrap or replace) are still provided
by abstract_replication_strategy.
TODO:
- effective_replication_map registry
- Move pending ranges from token_metadata to replication map
- get rid of abstract_replication_strategy::get_range_addresses(token_metadata&)
- calculate replication map and use it instead.
Test: unit(dev, debug)
Dtest: next-gating, bootstrap_test.py update_cluster_layout_tests.py alternator_tests.py -a 'dtest-full,!dtest-heavy' (release)
"
* tag 'effective_replication_strategy-v6' of github.com:bhalevy/scylla: (44 commits)
effective_replication_map: add get_range_addresses
abstract_replication_strategy: get rid of shared_token_metadata member and ctor param
abstract_replication_strategy: recognized_options: pass const topology&
abstract_replication_strategy: precacluate get_replication_factor for effective_replication_map
token_metadata: get rid of now-unused sync methods
abstract_replication_strategy: get rid of do_calculate_natural_endpoints
abstract_replication_strategy: futurize get_*address_ranges
abstract_replication_strategy: futurize get_range_addresses
abstract_replication_strategy: futurize get_ranges(inet_address ep, token_metadata_ptr)
abstract_replication_strategy: move get_ranges and get_primary_ranges* to effective_replication_map
compaction_manager: pass owned_ranges via cleanup/upgrade options
abstract_replication_strategy: get rid of cached_endpoints
all replication strategies: get rid of do_get_natural_endpoints
storage_proxy: use effective_replication_map token_metadata_ptr along with endpoints
abstract_replication_strategy: move get_natural_endpoints_without_node_being_replaced to effective_replication_map
storage_service: bootstrap: add log messages
storage_service: get_mutable_token_metadata_ptr: always invalidate_cached_rings
shared_token_metadata: set: check version monotonicity
token_metadata: use static ring version
token_metadata: get rid of copy constructor and assignment operator
...
Make a reader that reads from memtable in reverse order.
This draft PR includes two commits, out of which only the second is
relevant for review.
Described in #9133.
Refs #1413.
Closes#9174
* github.com:scylladb/scylla:
partition_snapshot_reader: pop_range_tombstone returns reference (instead of value) when possible.
memtable: enable native reversing
partition_snapshot_reader: reverse ck_range when needed by Reversing
memtable, partition_snapshot_reader: read from partition in reverse
partition_snapshot_reader: rows_position and rows_iter_type supporting reverse iteration
partition_snapshot_reader: split responsibility of ck_range
partition_snapshot_reader: separate _schema into _query_schema and _partition_schema
query: reverse clustering_range
test: cql_query_test: fix test_query_limit for reversed queries
It is not used any more.
Methods either use the token_metadata_ptr in the
effective_replication_map, or receive an ad-hoc
token_metadata.
Signed-off-by: Benny Halevy <bhalevy@scylladb.com>
Provide a sync get_ranges method by effective_replication_map
that uses the precalculated map to get all token ranges owned by or
replicated on a given endpoint.
Reuse do_get_ranges as common infrastructure for all
3 cases: get_ranges, get_primary_ranges, and get_primary_ranges_within_dc.
Signed-off-by: Benny Halevy <bhalevy@scylladb.com>
So they can be easily computed using an async task
before constructing the compaction object
in a following patch.
Signed-off-by: Benny Halevy <bhalevy@scylladb.com>
Serialize the metadata changes with
keyspace create, update, or drop.
This will become necessary in the following patch
when we update the effective_replication_map
on all keyspaces and we want instances on all shards
end up with the same replication map.
Note that storage_service::keyspace_changed is called
from the scheme_merge path so it already holds
the merge_lock.
Signed-off-by: Benny Halevy <bhalevy@scylladb.com>
And with that rename calculate_natural_endpoints(const token& search_token, const token_metadata&, can_yield)
to do_calculate_natural_endpoints and make it protected,
With this patch, all its external users call the async version, so
rename it back to calculate_natural_endpoints, and make
calculate_natural_endpoints_sync private since it's being called
only within abstract_replication_strategy.
Signed-off-by: Benny Halevy <bhalevy@scylladb.com>
The service level controller was initialized with a data
accessor that uses the system distributed keyspace before
the later have been initialized. If there is a use of
this accessor (for example by calling
to: service_level_controller::get_distributed_service_levels())
if will fail miserably and crash.
Not initializing the data accessor doesn't mean the same thing
since we can deal with such call when the accessor is not
initialized.
Signed-off-by: Eliran Sinvani <eliransin@scylladb.com>
Issue #8203 describes a bug in a long scan which returns a lot of empty
pages (e.g., because most of the results are filtered out). We have two
cql-pytest test cases that reproduced this bug - one for a whole-table
scan and one for a single-partition scan.
It turned out that the bug was not in the Scylla server, but actually in
the Python driver which incorrectly stopped the iteration after an empty
page even though this page did contain the "more pages" flag.
This driver bug was already fixed in the Datastax driver (see
6ed53d9f70,
and in the Scylla fork of the driver:
1d9077d3f4
So in this patch we drop the XFAIL, and if the driver is not new enough
to contain this fix - the test is skipped.
Since our Jenkins machines have the latest Scylla fork of the driver and
it already contains this fix, these tests will not be skipped - and will
run and should pass. Developers who run these tests on their development
machine will see these tests either passing or skipped - depending on
which version of the driver they have installed.
Closes#8203
Signed-off-by: Nadav Har'El <nyh@scylladb.com>
Message-Id: <20211011113848.698935-1-nyh@scylladb.com>
Our source base drifted away from gcc compatibility; this mostly
restores the ability to build with gcc. An important exception is
coroutines that have an initializer list [1]; this still doesn't work.
We aim to switch back to gcc 11 if/when this gives us better
C++ compatibility and performance.
Test: unit (dev)
[1] https://gcc.gnu.org/bugzilla/show_bug.cgi?id=98056Closes#9459
* github.com:scylladb/scylla:
test: radix_tree_printer: avoid template specialization in class context
test: raft: avoid ignored variable errors
test: reader_concurrency_semaphore_test: isolate from namespace of source_location
test: cql_query_test: drop unused lambda assert_replication_not_contains
test: commitlog_test: don't use deprecated seastar::unaligned_cast
test: adjust signed/unsigned comparisons in loops and boost tests
build: silence some gcc 11 warnings
sstables: processing_result_generator: make coroutine support palatable for C++20 compilers
managed_bytes: avoid compile-time loop in converting constructor
service: service_level_controller: drop unused variable sl_compare
raft: disambiguate promise name in raft::active_read
locator: azure_snitch: use full type name in definition of globals
cql3: statements: create_service_level_statement: don't ignore replace_defaults()
cql3: statement_restrictions: adjust call to std::vector deduction guide
types: remove recursive constraint in deserialize_value
cql3: restrictions: relax constraint on visitor_with_binary_operator_content
treewide: handle switch statements that return
cql3: expr: correct type of captured map value_type
cdc: adjust type of streams_count
alternator: disambiguate attrs_to_get in table_requests
Most of the methods are marked public, but only few of them should.
Test needs a bit more, however, so the distributed_loader_for_tests
is declared as friend class.
Signed-off-by: Pavel Emelyanov <xemul@scylladb.com>
This commit consists of changes, which need to reside in a single
commit, so that the tests pass on each of the commits.
1. Remove do_make_flat_reader which disabled reverse reads by making the
slice a forward one. Remove call to get_ranges which would do
superfluous reversal of clustering ranges.
2. test: cql_query_test: remove expectation that the test_query_limit
fails for reversed queries, since reversed queries no longer require
linear memory wrt. the result size, when paginated.
gcc complains about comparing a signed loop induction variable
with an unsigned limit, or comparing an expected value and measured
value. Fix by using unsigned throughout, except in one case where
the signed value was needed for the data_value constructor.
sstables_manager superseeds previous implementation of sstables_tracker
for tracking lifetime of the tables. Update scylla-gdb.py to use
sstables_manager in a backwards compatible way, as sstables_manager is
not available in Scylla Enterprise 2020.1. Add explicit test for
"scylla sstables" command, as previously only "scylla active-sstables"
was tested.
Closes#9439
pytest supports - if the "repeat" extension is installed - a convenient
and efficient way to repeat the same test (or all of them) multiple times.
Since it's very useful, let's document it in cql-pytest/README.md.
By the way, our test.py also has a "--repeat" option, but it can only run
all cql-pytest tests, not just repeat a single small test, and it is also
slower (and arguably, different) because it restarts Scylla instead of
running a test 100 times on the same Scylla.
Signed-off-by: Nadav Har'El <nyh@scylladb.com>
Message-Id: <20211007122146.624210-1-nyh@scylladb.com>
The test generates random mutations and eliminates mutations whose keys
tokenize to 0, in particular it eliminates mutations with empty
partition keys (which should not end up in sstables).
However it would do that after using the randomly generated mutations to
create their reversed versions. So the reversed versions of mutations
with empty partition keys would stay.
Fix by placing the workaround earlier in the test.
Closes#9447
I stumbled upon this failure in dev mode:
```
test/boost/sstable_conforms_to_mutation_source_test.cc(0): Entering test case "test_sstable_reversing_reader_random_schema"
sstable_conforms_to_mutation_source_test: ./seastar/src/core/fstream.cc:205: virtual seastar::file_data_source_impl::~file_data_source_impl(): Assertion `_reads_in_progress == 0' failed.
Aborting on shard 0.
```
Since dev mode has no debug symbols I can't
decode the stack trace so I'm not 100% sure about
the root cause and I couldn't reproduce it in release
or debug modes yet.
One vulnerability in the current code is that r1
won't be closed if an exception is thrown before r1 and r2
are moved to `compare_readers` so this change adds
a deferred close of r1 in this case.
Test: sstable_conforms_to_mutation_source_test(dev)
Signed-off-by: Benny Halevy <bhalevy@scylladb.com>
Message-Id: <20211006144009.696412-1-bhalevy@scylladb.com>
This is a translation of Cassandra's CQL unit test source file
validation/operations/SelectOrderByTest.java into our our cql-pytest
framework.
This test file includes 17 tests for various features and corners of
SELECT's "ORDER BY" feature. All these tests pass on Cassandra, but
three fail on Scylla and are marked as xfail:
One previously-unknown Scylla bug:
Refs #9435: SELECT with IN, ORDER BY and function call does not obey
the ORDER BY
And two new reproducers for already known bugs:
Refs #2247: ORDER BY should allow skipping equality-restricted
clustering columns
Refs #7751: Allow selecting map values and set elements, like in
Cassandra 4.0
Signed-off-by: Nadav Har'El <nyh@scylladb.com>
Message-Id: <20211005174140.571056-1-nyh@scylladb.com>
Ever since we started testing Alternator with tests written in Python
and using Amazon's "boto3" library, one limitation kept annoying us:
Boto3 verifies the validity of the request parameters before passing
them on to the server. It verifies that mandatory parameters are not
missing, that parameters have the right types, and sometimes even the
right ranges - all in the library before ever sending the request.
This meant that in many cases, we couldn't get good test coverage for
Alternator's server-side handling of *wrong* parameters.
As it turns out, it is trivial to tell boto3 to *not* do its client-side
request validation, with the `parameter_validation=False` config flag.
We just never noticed that such a flag existed :-)
So this patch adds this flag. It then fixes a few tests which expected
ParameterValidationError - this error is the client-side validation
failure, but should now be replaced by checking the server-side error.
The patch also adds a couple of invalid parameter checks that we
couldn't do before because of boto3's eagerness to check them on the
client side. We can add a lot more of these error tests in the future,
now that we got rid of client-side validation.
Signed-off-by: Nadav Har'El <nyh@scylladb.com>
Message-Id: <20211005095514.537226-1-nyh@scylladb.com>
This patch adds yet another test for Alternator's unimplemented feature
of adding a GSI to an already existing table (issue #5022), but this
test is for a very specific corner case - tables which contain string
attributes with an empty value - the corner case described in
issue #9424:
DynamoDB used to forbid any string attributes from being set to an empty
string, but this changed in May 2020, and since then empty strings are
allowed - but NOT as keys. So although it is legal to set a string
attribute to an empty string, if this table has a GSI whose key is that
specific attribute, the update command is refused. We already had a
test for this - test_gsi_empty_value.
However, the case in this patch is the case where a GSI is added to a
table *after* the table already has data. In this case (as this test
demonstrates), we are supposed to drop the items which have the empty
string key from the GSI.
Even when #5022 (the ability to add GSIs to existing tables) will be done,
this test will continue to fail. The unique problem of this test is that
Scylla's materialized views *do* allow empty strings as clustering keys
(right now) and even partition keys (after #9375 will be solved), while
we don't want them to enter the GSI. We will probably need to add to the
view's filter, which right now contains (as required) "x IS NOT NULL"
also the filter "x != ''" (when x's type is a string or binary) so that
items with empty-string keys will be dropped.
Refs #5022
Refs #9375
Refs #9424
Signed-off-by: Nadav Har'El <nyh@scylladb.com>
Message-Id: <20211003170636.477582-1-nyh@scylladb.com>
DynamoDB has a rather baroque definition of numbers, and in particular
it does *not* allow numeric attributes to be set to infinity or NaN.
Although I did check invalid numbers in the past, manually, I was never
able to write a unit test for this in the past - because the boto3
library catches such errors on the client side, and prevents the test from
sending broken requests to the server. So in this patch, I finally came up
with a solution - a context manager client_no_transform() which
yields a client which does NOT do any transformation or validation
on the request's parameters, allowing us to use boto3 to create
improper requests - and test the server's handling of them.
The test in this patch passes - it did not discover a new bug, but
it is a useful regression test and the client_no_transform() trick
can be used in more error-case tests which until now we were unable
to write.
Signed-off-by: Nadav Har'El <nyh@scylladb.com>
Message-Id: <20211004161809.520236-1-nyh@scylladb.com>
This allows us to forward-declare raw_selector, which in turn reduces
indirect inclusions of expression.hh from 147 to 58, reducing rebuilds
when anything in that area changes.
Includes that were lost due to the change are restored in individual
translation units.
Closes#9434
base64.hh pulls in the huge rjson.hh, so if someone just wants
a base64 codec they have to pull in the entire rapidjson library.
Move the json related parts of base64.hh to rjson.hh and adjust
includes and namespaces.
In practice it doesn't make much difference, as all users of base64
appear to want json too. But it's cleaner not to mix the two.
Closes#9433
"
There's a run_mutation_source_tests lib helper that runs a bunch of
tests sequentially. The problem is that it does 4 different flavors
of it each being a certain decoration over provided reader. This
amplification makes some test cases run enormous amount of time
without any chance for parallelizm.
The simplest way to help running those cases in parallel is to teach
the slowest cases to run different flavors of mutation source tests
in dedicated cases. This patch makes it so.
The resulting timings are
dev debug
sequential run: 2m1s 53m50s
--parallel-cases (+ this patch): 1m3s 31m15s
tests: unit(dev, debug)
"
* 'br-parallel-mutation-source-tests' of https://github.com/xemul/scylla:
test: Split multishard combining reader case
test: Split database test case
test: Split run_mutation_source_tests
(Single-partition) reversed queries are no longer unlimited but some
places still treat them as such. This causes, for example, shorter pages
for such queries, which breaks a test that expects certain results to
come in a single page.
It's possible that the server drops the snapshot in the same iteration
of `io_fiber` loop as it tries to send it (the sending of messages
happens after snapshot dropping). Handle this case.
Refs #9407.
All the cases in this test also run mutation source tests and the
case with single-fragment buffer takes times more time to execute
than the others.
Splitting this single case so that it runs mutation source tests
flavours in different cases improves the test parallelizm.
Signed-off-by: Pavel Emelyanov <xemul@scylladb.com>
The test_database_with_data_in_sstables_is_a_mutation_source case runs
the mutation source tests in one go. The problem is that on each step
a whole new ks:cf is created which takes the majority of the tests time.
In the end of the day this case is the slowest one in the suite being
up to two times longer (depending on mode) than the #2 on this list.
This patch splits the case into 4 so that each mutation source flavor
is run in separate case.
Signed-off-by: Pavel Emelyanov <xemul@scylladb.com>
There are 4 flavours of mutation source tests that are all ran
sequentially -- plain, reversed and upgrade/downgrade ones that
check v1<->v2 conversions.
This patch splits them all into individual calls so that some
tests may want to have dedicated cases for each. "By default" they
are all run as they were.
Signed-off-by: Pavel Emelyanov <xemul@scylladb.com>
The previous check would find a leader once and assume that it does not
change, and that the first attempt at sending a request to this leader
succeeds. In reality the leader may change at the end of the test (e.g.
it may be in the middle of stepping down when we find it) and in general
it may take some time for the cluster to stabilize. The new check tries
a few times to find a leader and perform a request - until a time limit
is reached.
The commit also removes an incorrect assertion inside in `wait_for_leader`.
Until now reversed queries were implemented inside
`querier::consume_page` (more precisely, inside the free function
`consume_page` used by `querier::consume_page`) by wrapping the
passed-in reader into `make_reversing_reader` and then consuming
fragments from the resulting reversed reader.
The first couple of commits change that by pushing the reversing down below
the `make_combined_reader` call in `table::query`. This allows
working on improving reversing for memtables independently from
reversing for sstables.
We then extend the `index_reader` with functions that allow
reading the promoted index in reverse.
We introduce `partition_reversing_data_source`, which wraps an sstable data
file and returns data buffers with contents of a single chosen partition
as if the rows were stored in reverse order.
We use the reversing source and the extended index reader in
`mx_sstable_mutation_reader` to implement efficient (at least in theory)
reversed single-partition reads.
The patchset disables cache for reversed reads. Fast-forwarding
is not supported in the mx reader for reversed queries at this point.
Details in commit messages. Read the commits in topological order
for best review experience.
Refs: #9134
(not saying "Fixes" because it's only for single-partition queries
without forwarding)
Closes#9281
* github.com:scylladb/scylla:
table: add option to automatically bypass cache for reversed queries
test: reverse sstable reader with random schema and random mutations
sstables: mx: implement reversed single-partition reads
sstables: mx: introduce partition_reversing_data_source
sstables: index_reader: add support for iterating over clustering ranges in reverse
clustering_key_filter: clustering_key_filter_ranges owning constructor
flat_mutation_reader: mention reversed schema in make_reversing_reader docstring
clustering_key_filter: document clustering_key_filter_ranges::get_ranges
The test generates a random set of mutations and creates two readers:
- one by reversing the mutations, creating an sstable out of the result,
and querying it in reverse,
- one by creating an sstable directly from the mutations and querying it
in forward mode.
It checks that the readers give equal results.
The test already managed to find a bug where offsets returned by the
sstable index were interpreted incorrectly as absolute instead of
relative. It also helped find another bug unrelated to reversing (#9352).
Surprisingly few tests use the random schema and random mutation
utilities which seem to be quite powerful.
"
The storage_service is involved in the cdc_generation_service guts
more than needed.
- the bool _for_testing bit is cdc-only
- there's API-only cdc_generation_service getter
- cdc_g._s. startup code partially sits in s._s. one
This patch cleans most of the above leaving only the startup
_cdc_gen_id on board.
tests: unit(dev)
refs: #2795
"
* 'br-storage-service-vs-cdc-2' of https://github.com/xemul/scylla:
api: Use local sharded<cdc::generation_service> reference
main: Push cdc::generation_service via API
storage_service: Ditch for_testing boolean
cdc: Replace db::config with generation_service::config
cdc: Drop db::config from description_generator
cdc: Remove all arguments from maybe_rewrite_streams_descriptions
cdc: Move maybe_rewrite_streams_descriptions into after_join
cdc: Squash two methods into one
cdc: Turn make_new_cdc_generation a service method
cdc: Remove ring-delay arg from make_new_cdc_generation
cdc: Keep database reference on generation_service
