Commit Graph

2 Commits

Author SHA1 Message Date
Piotr Dulikowski
742f2abfd8 exception_container: do not throw in accept
This commit changes the behavior of `exception_container::accept`. Now,
instead of throwing an `utils::bad_exception_container_access` exception
when the container is empty, the provided visitor is invoked with that
exception instead. There are two reasons for this change:

- The exception_container is supposed to allow handling exceptions
  without using the costly C++'s exception runtime. Although an empty
  container is an edge case, I think it the new behavior is more aligned
  with the class' purpose. The old behavior can be simulated by
  providing a visitor which throws when called with bad access
  exception.

- The new behavior fixes a bug in `result_try`/`result_futurize_try`.
  Before the change, if the `try` block returned a failed result with an
  empty exception container, a bad access exception would either be
  thrown or returned as an exceptional future without being handled by
  the `catch` clauses. Although nobody is supposed to return such
  result<>s on purpose, a moved out result can be returned by accident
  and it's important for the exception handling logic to be correct in
  such a situation.

Tests: unit(dev)

Closes #10086
2022-02-16 10:06:10 +02:00
Piotr Dulikowski
80f6224959 utils: add exception_container
Adds `exception_container` - a helper type used to hold exceptions as a
value, without involving the std::exception_ptr.

The motivation behind this type is that it allows inspecting exception's
type and value without having to rethrow that exception and catch it,
unlike std::exception_ptr. In our current codebase, some exception
handling paths need to rethrow the exception multiple times in order to
account it into metrics or encode it as an error response to the CQL
client. Some types of exceptions can be thrown very frequently in case
of overload (e.g. timeouts) and inspecting those exceptions with
rethrows can make the overload even worse. For those kinds of exceptions
it is important to handle them as cheaply as possible, and
exception_container used with conjunction with boost::outcome::result
can help achieve that.
2022-02-04 20:18:00 +01:00