mirror of
https://github.com/scylladb/scylladb.git
synced 2026-05-13 11:22:01 +00:00
3f72852d8c
Fix 28 format string bugs plus 5 related format argument bugs across 14 modules
where `{}` placeholders were missing or arguments were wrong, causing arguments to
be silently dropped or misleading output from the `{fmt}` library.
Inspired by https://github.com/scylladb/scylladb/pull/29143 (which fixed a single
instance in `replica/table.cc`), a comprehensive audit of the entire codebase was
performed to find all similar issues.
- **Missing `{}` placeholder** (21 instances): format string simply lacks `{}` for a
passed argument, e.g. `format("msg for table {}", group_id, table_id)` -- `group_id`
is silently dropped
- **Spurious comma breaking C++ string literal concatenation** (2 instances): a comma
after a string literal prevents adjacent-literal concatenation, turning the
continuation into a format argument instead of part of the format string
- **Printf-style `%s` in fmtlib context** (4 instances): `%s` has no meaning in fmtlib
and appears as literal text while the argument is silently ignored
- **Extra spurious argument** (1 instance): an extraneous `t.tomb()` argument inserted
between correct arguments, causing wrong values in the wrong slots
- **Wrong variable in error message** (4 instances in `types/map.hh`): error messages
for oversized map keys/values reported `map_size` (total entry count) instead of the
actual `elem.first.size()` or `elem.second.size()` that exceeded the limit
- **Swapped argument order** (1 instance in `data_dictionary/data_dictionary.cc`):
format string says `"Extraneous options for {type}: {values}"` but the values and
type arguments were passed in reverse order
| Module | Bugs Fixed | Files |
|--------|:---------:|-------|
| `replica/` | 1 | `table.cc` |
| `service/` | 4 | `raft_group0.cc`, `storage_service.cc` |
| `db/` | 6 | `heat_load_balance.cc`, `commitlog_replayer.cc`, `view_update_generator.cc`, `view_building_worker.cc`, `row_locking.cc` |
| `cql3/` | 2 | `prepare_expr.cc`, `statement_restrictions.cc` |
| `transport/` | 4 | `event_notifier.cc` |
| `sstables/` | 3 | `partition_reversing_data_source.cc`, `reader.cc` |
| `alternator/` | 1 | `conditions.cc` |
| `cdc/` | 1 | `split.cc` |
| `raft/` | 1 | `server.cc` |
| `utils/` | 2 | `gcp/object_storage.cc`, `s3/client.cc` |
| `mutation/` | 1 | `mutation_partition.hh` |
| `ent/` | 2 | `kmip_host.cc`, `kms_host.cc` |
| `types/` | 4 | `map.hh` |
| `data_dictionary/` | 1 | `data_dictionary.cc` |
The `{fmt}` library's compile-time checker validates that each `{}` placeholder
references a valid argument, but does **not** verify the reverse -- that every
argument has a corresponding placeholder. Extra arguments are silently ignored
at both compile time and runtime.
Build verified with `dbuild ninja build/dev/scylla` -- compiles cleanly.
---
**Note:** Commits were amended to fix the author name from "Yaniv Michael Kaul" to "Yaniv Kaul".
Closes scylladb/scylladb#29448
* github.com:scylladb/scylladb:
data_dictionary: fix swapped arguments in extraneous options error
types: fix wrong variable in map key/value size error messages
ent: fix missing format placeholders in encryption error/log messages
mutation: fix spurious argument in shadowable_tombstone formatter
utils: fix missing format placeholders in object storage log messages
raft: fix missing format placeholder in server ostream operator
cdc: fix missing format placeholder in error message
alternator: fix missing format placeholder in error message
sstables: fix missing format placeholders in error messages
transport: fix printf-style format specifiers in fmtlib log calls
cql3: fix missing format placeholders in error messages
db: fix missing format placeholders in log and error messages
service: fix missing format placeholders in log messages
replica: fix missing format placeholder in cleanup log message