Files
scylladb/service
Pavel Emelyanov b43454c658 cql: Check that CREATEing tablets/vnodes is consistent with the CLI
There are two bits that control whenter replication strategy for a
keyspace will use tablets or not -- the configuration option and CQL
parameter. This patch tunes its parsing to implement the logic shown
below:

    if (strategy.supports_tablets) {
         if (cql.with_tablets) {
             if (cfg.enable_tablets) {
                 return create_keyspace_with_tablets();
             } else {
                 throw "tablets are not enabled";
             }
         } else if (cql.with_tablets = off) {
              return create_keyspace_without_tablets();
         } else { // cql.with_tablets is not specified
              if (cfg.enable_tablets) {
                  return create_keyspace_with_tablets();
              } else {
                  return create_keyspace_without_tablets();
              }
         }
     } else { // strategy doesn't support tablets
         if (cql.with_tablets == on) {
             throw "invalid cql parameter";
         } else if (cql.with_tablets == off) {
             return create_keyspace_without_tablets();
         } else { // cql.with_tablets is not specified
             return create_keyspace_without_tablets();
         }
     }

closes: #20088

In order to enable tablets "by default" for NetworkTopologyStrategy
there's explicit check near ks_prop_defs::get_initial_tablets(), that's
not very nice. It needs more care to fix it, e.g. provide feature
service reference to abstract_replication_strategy constructor. But
since ks_prop_defs code already highjacks options specifically for that
strategy type (see prepare_options() helper), it's OK for now.

There's also #20768 misbehavior that's preserved in this patch, but
should be fixed eventually as well.

Signed-off-by: Pavel Emelyanov <xemul@scylladb.com>
(cherry picked from commit ebedc57300)

Closes scylladb/scylladb#20927
2024-10-03 17:09:49 +03:00
..
2024-06-07 06:44:59 +08:00