5 Commits
Author SHA1 Message Date
Chris LuandGitHub b45f8314c5 ec.encode: require the shards to agree on size before deleting the volume (#10769)
* ec.encode: require the shards to agree on size before deleting the volume

Before an encode deletes the volume it just encoded, it asks whether
enough shards exist and whether they are spread across nodes. Both are
questions about presence: nothing asks whether those shards are whole.

Every shard takes one piece of each block row, so they are all written to
the same length. One that disagrees was truncated, half copied, or landed
on a disk that filled up -- and counting cannot see it, so the source
volume is deleted on the strength of a set that cannot rebuild it.

Compare the sizes the cluster already reports (shard_sizes travels in the
heartbeat) and hold the deletion back when they disagree, naming the odd
shard and its holder. Sizes reported as zero are skipped rather than read
as a disagreement: a volume server that predates shard-size reporting, or
one that has not heartbeated them yet, must not strand every encode in
the volume-plus-shards state this check exists to avoid.

* ec.encode: judge shard sizes on the newest encode generation only

The size check collected every shard the master reports for the volume,
while the recoverability check beside it counts only the newest encode
generation. A re-encode can change the ratio, so an orphaned older
generation -- one the pre-encode sweep could not reach, but the master
still hears about -- has shards of a different length by nature. Merging
those into the comparison makes a healthy current set look inconsistent,
and because the orphan keeps being reported, every retry fails and the
encode is left holding the volume and its shards for good.

Collect sizes the way CollectEcShardBitsByNode collects bits: fenced to
the newest EncodeTsNs, with unstamped entries forming the one legacy
generation.
2026-08-15 14:21:13 -07:00
Chris LuandGitHub 829064af71 ec.decode: finish the cleanup an interrupted decode left behind (#10767)
A decode deletes the shards only after the regenerated volume is mounted
and verified, so a run interrupted in that last phase leaves the volume
in place with its shards partway through deletion. The re-run then finds
both, tries to collect the shards again to rebuild a volume that already
exists, and fails on the first shard the interrupted run had removed:

  generate normal volume 3 ...: ec volume 3 missing shard 6

Nothing recovers from there: the shard set is deliberately being
destroyed, so every retry fails the same way while the decoded volume
sits there, already complete.

Finish that cleanup instead. A volume beside the shards is not enough to
act on -- an encode interrupted before it deleted the original leaves the
same shape, as does a decode killed while generating, whose volume may be
half written -- so require a data shard to be gone. Only the deletion
phase removes one, and it is also exactly the state no decode can
recover from, so finishing is the only move left rather than a choice
between two. The deletion still runs behind
verifyDecodedVolumeBeforeDelete, the check that guards it in a normal
run.
2026-08-15 13:04:37 -07:00
Chris LuandGitHub 1c926e8fac test: systematic EC interruption verification — exhaustive model check + deterministic kill matrix (#10764)
* ec: bounded-exhaustive model check of the volume lifecycle

The randomized chaos harness samples the state space; this enumerates
it. The lifecycle is a state machine whose steps mirror the pipelines in
this package, and the checker explores every schedule within the bound:
a crash at every step boundary, an error return running the rollback
(itself crashable at every step), a volume-server restart applying the
startup reconciliation rules in every quiescent state, and the
prescribed restart-based recovery from every crashed state.

Checked in every reachable state: durability (a readable copy always
exists), at most one generation mounted, and — a property the sweep
discipline turns out to guarantee — at most one generation's files on
disk. From every quiescent state the recovery must converge to a clean
volume. Runs in well under a second.

* test: deterministic EC interruption matrix

Enumerate every phase of every interruptible EC operation and kill a
real weed shell exactly when the phase announces itself on the command
output, instead of at a random moment: four encode phases, four decode
phases, and the balance's move phase (set up with -rebalance=false so a
move is guaranteed). Each scenario prepares its precondition, kills at
the marker, runs the prescribed recovery, and verifies every stored byte
still reads back identical.

The interruption recoveries move out of the randomized ops into shared
chaosRun helpers both drivers use.

* test: make the randomized EC chaos walk opt-in

The systematic layers — the interruption matrix and the lifecycle model
check — carry the CI coverage deterministically; the randomized walk
stays for exploratory runs, behind EC_CHAOS_SEED.

* ci: bound the EC integration suite by the job budget, not go test's default

The suite with the interruption matrix runs close to the default 10m
binary timeout on slower runners.

* test: require every interruption-matrix marker to appear

A marker that never prints means a pipeline refactor renamed or dropped
the progress line; silently degenerating into a no-interruption run
would let CI pass without exercising the boundary the scenario names.
Also recheck the marker channel after the wait: a shell that prints and
exits at once makes both channels ready, and select picking the exit
case must not report a printed marker as missed.
2026-08-14 17:45:11 -07:00
Chris LuandGitHub 602746f51d test: EC lifecycle chaos harness, with four fixes it found (#10763)
* ec: let the encode's balance see a migrating volume's shards across disk-type buckets

Shard generation writes beside the source .dat, so a cross-tier encode
(source on hdd, -diskType=ssd) leaves the fresh shards in the source
disk-type bucket. The encode's internal balance ingested only the target
bucket, saw no shards, and planned no moves; the spread guard then
correctly aborted the encode (and before that guard existed, the shards
silently stayed clumped on the generation host in the wrong tier).

EcBalance now takes the encode batch as migratingVolumeIds and ingests
those volumes' shards from every bucket, while everything else keeps the
bucket filter so a plain ec.balance never drags deliberately tiered
shards onto another disk type. The in-memory model delete also becomes
bucket-agnostic: a node holds a given shard in exactly one bucket, and a
bucket-scoped delete missed cross-bucket moves in the dry-run model.

* volume: decode reads shard 0 from its resolved path, not the EC volume's base dir

On a multi-disk server a volume's shards can sit on several disks; the
store registers each shard with its own path and CollectEcShards resolves
them, but FindDatFileSize derived the .ec00 path from the EcVolume's base
directory. When shard 0 lived on a sibling disk, VolumeEcShardsToVolume
failed with 'open ...ec00: no such file or directory' and ec.decode
aborted.

* ec: decode re-copies shards the topology claims but the target does not hold

An interrupted earlier decode or balance can leave the master believing
the decode target holds a shard whose file never landed: the mount
registered but the partial copy was cleaned, or the file was swept. The
collect step took the topology's word for it, excluded the shard from
the copy set, and the decode failed with 'missing shard'. Probe the
target's live inventory (VolumeEcShardsInfo) and treat anything it
cannot serve as still-to-copy.

* ec: decode discovers shards across disk-type buckets

Shards sit wherever encode generation and balance left them: a
cross-tier encode leaves them in the source disk-type bucket, a partial
migration straddles buckets. ec.decode scoped its shard discovery to the
-diskType bucket and reported a decodable volume as having no shards at
all. Union across buckets, the way the encode's shard verification
already does.

* test: EC chaos lifecycle harness

Randomized, seeded sequences of the EC lifecycle against a live cluster
in the production-shaped layout: multiple data disks per server, a
separate -dir.idx directory so .ecx/.ecj sidecars are shared across
disks, and a tagged ssd tier. Operations cover encode (hdd and ssd
targets), balance, shard damage plus rebuild, decode, re-encode,
deletes, scrub, tier moves, crash-restarts, sidecar fault injections
(a data-dir .vif pushed into the shared idx dir; a stale-generation
shard planted beside a newer encode), and interruptions: a real weed
shell subprocess killed mid-encode, mid-decode, and mid-balance, with
the recovery re-run required to converge.

One invariant holds after every step: every stored byte reads back
identical and every deleted needle stays deleted. EC_CHAOS_SEED and
EC_CHAOS_STEPS make runs reproducible and scalable.

A known gap is tolerated and logged rather than fixed here: a shard
mounted on two disks of one node (orphan adoption after an interrupted
copy) is invisible to ec.balance's dedup and unaddressable by
ec.shard.unmount's shard@address form, so no cleanup path exists yet.

* test: fail payload-corruption checks on the test goroutine

t.Fatalf inside require.Eventually's condition runs on the poller's
goroutine, where Goexit kills only that goroutine and the corruption
message can be lost behind a generic timeout. Record the mismatch, end
the polling, and fail on the test goroutine. Also assert the full shard
count in the cross-bucket decode-discovery test.
2026-08-14 17:26:54 -07:00
Chris LuandGitHub 944d967502 refactor: extract EC orchestration into a shared weed/ec package (#10760)
* shell: move ErrorWaitGroup to weed/util

* shell: remove unused CandidateEcNode and EcRack types

* ec: extract EC orchestration logic from weed/shell into weed/ec

Move the EC node/topology model, balance engine, encode pipeline, decode
pipeline, and rebuild engine into a new weed/ec package so shell commands
and maintenance workers can share the logic. Shell commands keep flag
parsing and delegate through a small ec.Env (dial option, topology fetch,
volume locations, lock check). Tests move along with the code.

* shell: remove unused proportional-rebalance type stubs

* ec: move scrub, replication check, and shard unmount engines into weed/ec

* worker: share the EC generation-aware shard counter from weed/ec

* ec: gofmt

* shell: drop EC aliases with no remaining callers

* ec: guard a missing topology hook and nil disk entries in topology helpers

* ec: drop trailing newlines from decode error strings

* ec: re-check the shell lock before applying shard unmounts

* shell: trim -node entries in ec.scrub
2026-08-14 13:54:12 -07:00