Commit Graph

2 Commits

Author SHA1 Message Date
Chris Lu e12052ee6b fix(filer.sync): replicate a rename as an atomic move, not a no-op update (#9895)
* fix(filer.sync): replicate a rename as create-then-delete, not an in-place update

A rename arrives as a single metadata event carrying both the old and new
entry. The filer sink was routed to UpdateEntry, which looks up the old
path but issues the update against the new parent without changing the
name — and the filer UpdateEntry RPC cannot move an entry. So the rename
was dropped: the old path lingered and the new path never appeared
(same-dir renames rewrote the old name in place).

Route a real move (the sink path changed) through CreateEntry(new) then
DeleteEntry(old) in both the replicator and the filer.sync/backup driver,
the way the other sinks already handle it; reach UpdateEntry only for true
in-place updates. Create before delete so a crash between the two leaves
the entry visible rather than lost.

* fix(filer.sync): derive the rename delete key like the create key, guard the watched root

The rename delete leg rebuilt the old key with a raw util.Join, bypassing the
sink-side key normalization the create leg gets from buildKey — so a rename
could create the new entry and then fail to delete the old one under a
transformed key. Build the old key through buildKey too, and skip the delete
when the moved entry is the watched root itself (where the old key would
resolve to the target root and recursively delete the whole sink tree).

* test(filer.sync): cover the in-place update delete-then-create fallback order

The recording sinks always reported foundExisting, so the fallback that an
in-place update takes when the entry is missing on the sink was never run.
Make it configurable and assert the fallback deletes before it recreates the
same key, in both the replicator and the filer.sync drivers.

* feat(filer.sync): move filer-sink renames natively via AtomicRenameEntry

create-then-delete is unsafe for the filer sink: CreateEntry returns nil
without creating on a transient chunk-copy error, so the paired delete could
remove the only valid destination copy; a directory rename also deleted the
old subtree before descendants were recreated, and left old chunks behind.

Add an optional EntryMover sink capability and implement it on the filer sink
via AtomicRenameEntry — one atomic, metadata-only move that relocates a whole
subtree in a single transaction. Renames prefer it; sinks without a native
move keep create-then-delete. When the old path is already gone (a descendant
the parent rename moved, or one never replicated) MoveEntry creates the new
path instead, re-checking existence with a lookup so a rolled-back move that
left the old entry intact is retried rather than mistaken for gone.

* docs(filer.sync): note entryMissing's gRPC not-found string fallback is deliberate
2026-06-09 12:54:28 -07:00
Chris Lu ced2236cc6 Adjust rename events metadata format (#8854)
* rename metadata events

* fix subscription filter to use NewEntry.Name for rename path matching

The server-side subscription filter constructed the new path using
OldEntry.Name instead of NewEntry.Name when checking if a rename
event's destination matches the subscriber's path prefix. This could
cause events to be incorrectly filtered when a rename changes the
file name.

* fix bucket events to handle rename of bucket directories

onBucketEvents only checked IsCreate and IsDelete. A bucket directory
rename via AtomicRenameEntry now emits a single rename event (both
OldEntry and NewEntry non-nil), which matched neither check. Handle
IsRename by deleting the old bucket and creating the new one.

* fix replicator to handle rename events across directory boundaries

Two issues fixed:

1. The replicator filtered events by checking if the key (old path)
   was under the source directory. Rename events now use the old path
   as key, so renames from outside into the watched directory were
   silently dropped. Now both old and new paths are checked, and
   cross-boundary renames are converted to create or delete.

2. NewParentPath was passed to the sink without remapping to the
   sink's target directory structure, causing the sink to write
   entries at the wrong location. Now NewParentPath is remapped
   alongside the key.

* fix filer sync to handle rename events crossing directory boundaries

The early directory-prefix filter only checked resp.Directory (old
parent). Rename events now carry the old parent as Directory, so
renames from outside the source path into it were dropped before
reaching the existing cross-boundary handling logic. Check both old
and new directories against sourcePath and excludePaths so the
downstream old-key/new-key logic can properly convert these to
create or delete operations.

* fix metadata event path matching

* fix metadata event consumers for rename targets

* Fix replication rename target keys

Logical rename events now reach replication sinks with distinct source and target paths.\n\nHandle non-filer sinks as delete-plus-create on the translated target key, and make the rename fallback path create at the translated target key too.\n\nAdd focused tests covering non-filer renames, filer rename updates, and the fallback path.\n\nCo-authored-by: Copilot <223556219+Copilot@users.noreply.github.com>

* Fix filer sync rename path scoping

Use directory-boundary matching instead of raw prefix checks when classifying source and target paths during filer sync.\n\nAlso apply excludePaths per side so renames across excluded boundaries downgrade cleanly to create/delete instead of being misclassified as in-scope updates.\n\nAdd focused tests for boundary matching and rename classification.\n\nCo-authored-by: Copilot <223556219+Copilot@users.noreply.github.com>

* Fix replicator directory boundary checks

Use directory-boundary matching instead of raw prefix checks when deciding whether a source or target path is inside the watched tree or an excluded subtree.\n\nThis prevents sibling paths such as /foo and /foobar from being misclassified during rename handling, and preserves the earlier rename-target-key fix.\n\nAdd focused tests for boundary matching and rename classification across sibling/excluded directories.\n\nCo-authored-by: Copilot <223556219+Copilot@users.noreply.github.com>

* Fix etc-remote rename-out handling

Use boundary-safe source/target directory membership when classifying metadata events under DirectoryEtcRemote.\n\nThis prevents rename-out events from being processed as config updates, while still treating them as removals where appropriate for the remote sync and remote gateway command paths.\n\nAdd focused tests for update/removal classification and sibling-prefix handling.\n\nCo-authored-by: Copilot <223556219+Copilot@users.noreply.github.com>

* Defer rename events until commit

Queue logical rename metadata events during atomic and streaming renames and publish them only after the transaction commits successfully.\n\nThis prevents subscribers from seeing delete or logical rename events for operations that later fail during delete or commit.\n\nAlso serialize notification.Queue swaps in rename tests and add failure-path coverage.\n\nCo-authored-by: Copilot <223556219+Copilot@users.noreply.github.com>

* Skip descendant rename target lookups

Avoid redundant target lookups during recursive directory renames once the destination subtree is known absent.\n\nThe recursive move path now inserts known-absent descendants directly, and the test harness exercises prefixed directory listing so the optimization is covered by a directory rename regression test.\n\nCo-authored-by: Copilot <223556219+Copilot@users.noreply.github.com>

* Tighten rename review tests

Return filer_pb.ErrNotFound from the bucket tracking store test stub so it follows the FilerStore contract, and add a webhook filter case for same-name renames across parent directories.\n\nCo-authored-by: Copilot <223556219+Copilot@users.noreply.github.com>

* fix HardLinkId format verb in InsertEntryKnownAbsent error

HardLinkId is a byte slice. %d prints each byte as a decimal number
which is not useful for an identifier. Use %x to match the log line
two lines above.

* only skip descendant target lookup when source and dest use same store

moveFolderSubEntries unconditionally passed skipTargetLookup=true for
every descendant. This is safe when all paths resolve to the same
underlying store, but with path-specific store configuration a child's
destination may map to a different backend that already holds an entry
at that path. Use FilerStoreWrapper.SameActualStore to check per-child
and fall back to the full CreateEntry path when stores differ.

* add nil and create edge-case tests for metadata event scope helpers

* extract pathIsEqualOrUnder into util.IsEqualOrUnder

Identical implementations existed in both replication/replicator.go and
command/filer_sync.go. Move to util.IsEqualOrUnder (alongside the
existing FullPath.IsUnder) and remove the duplicates.

* use MetadataEventTargetDirectory for new-side directory in filer sync

The new-side directory checks and sourceNewKey computation used
message.NewParentPath directly. If NewParentPath were empty (legacy
events, older filer versions during rolling upgrades), sourceNewKey
would be wrong (/filename instead of /dir/filename) and the
UpdateEntry parent path rewrite would panic on slice bounds.

Derive targetDir once from MetadataEventTargetDirectory, which falls
back to resp.Directory when NewParentPath is empty, and use it
consistently for all new-side checks and the sink parent path.
2026-03-30 18:25:11 -07:00