Michał Chojnowski fa7e904cd6 commitlog: fix total_size_on_disk accounting after segment file removal ...

Currently, segment file removal first calls `f.remove_file()` and
does `total_size_on_disk -= f.known_size()` later.
However, `remove_file()` resets `known_size` to 0, so in effect
the freed space in not accounted for.

`total_size_on_disk` is not just a metric. It is also responsible
for deciding whether a segment should be recycled -- it is recycled
only if `total_size_on_disk - known_size < max_disk_size`.
Therefore this bug has dire performance consequences:
if `total_size_on_disk - known_size` ever exceeds `max_disk_size`,
the recycling of commitlog segments will stop permanently, because
`total_size_on_disk - known_size` will never go back below
`max_disk_size` due to the accounting bug. All new segments from this
point will be allocated from scratch.

The bug was uncovered by a QA performance test. It isn't easy to trigger --
it took the test 7 hours of constant high load to step into it.
However, the fact that the effect is permanent, and degrades the
performance of the cluster silently, makes the bug potentially quite severe.

The bug can be easily spotted with Prometheus as infinitely rising
`commitlog_total_size_on_disk` on the affected shards.

Fixes #12645

Closes #12646

2023-01-30 12:20:04 +02:00

110 KiB

Raw Blame History

View Raw